Advertisement

Top Rated - Restaurants in Reykjavik

Finding the top rated restaurants in Reykjavik means looking beyond flashy marketing and focusing on spots that locals and visitors rave about after repeated visits. These places earn their high scores because real travellers have left numerous thoughtful reviews, not just one-off five stars. Many are scattered around neighborhoods like downtown’s Laugavegur or the Old Harbour, serving everything from fresh seafood to Icelandic comfort food with modern twists.

The best ones combine great food with consistent service and atmosphere, no matter the season. Winters can be calm, so booking ahead for popular spots is smart, especially if you want a window seat to watch the street life or the northern lights. If you want a tip, try to time your restaurant outings for weekdays or quieter hours. That way, you get the best experience without the big crowds. These top rated restaurants show what Reykjavik’s food scene is really about, straight from those who have tasted it.
🌍 Part of the My Guide Network 180+ destinations worldwide
Search by Map

Book Top Experiences and Tours in Reykjavik:

If you're booking your trip to Reykjavik last minute, we have you covered. Below are some of the top tours and experiences.

View All Experiences

Local tip for dining

If you want an insider’s tip, try dining a bit outside of peak hours. For example, heading out around 5 to 6 pm on a weekday can mean you avoid the busiest times and get more attentive service. Some of Reykjavik’s top rated spots are small, and during peak times they fill up with tourists and locals alike. Also, if the weather’s clear, ask for a seat by the window in places near the harbour. You might enjoy a glimpse of the sunset over the bay or in winter catch a chance to spot the northern lights while you eat.

Frequently Asked Questions

Your common questions about top rated restaurants in Reykjavik.

Look for restaurants with a large number of reviews showing consistent, strong ratings rather than a few isolated five-star reviews. Genuine traveller feedback over time is the best indicator.

Many top spots do lean toward the pricier side, reflecting Iceland’s overall cost of dining, but you’ll find options that offer great value, especially if you try lunch menus or less touristy neighborhoods.

Yes, especially during the tourist seasons or weekends. Popular places fill up fast, so a reservation helps guarantee a table and avoids disappointment.

You’ll find a good mix of traditional Icelandic dishes, fresh seafood, and contemporary takes on local ingredients. Many also include international influences, but Icelandic flavors usually take center stage.

Some are quite welcoming to families, but others cater more to adults or have limited space. Checking recent reviews or calling ahead helps to confirm if they can accommodate kids comfortably.

Yes, most well-rated restaurants now include vegetarian and vegan choices. Iceland’s dining scene has become much more inclusive in recent years, responding to varied dietary needs.

Downtown Reykjavik around Laugavegur and the Old Harbour area are good bets, as they have a concentration of highly rated places with a lively atmosphere and great access.

Explore Restaurants Categories

American (14 places) When it comes to American cuisine in Reykjavik, you'll find a variety of options ranging from classic burgers and fries to gourmet BBQ and juicy steaks. Head to the downtown area for trendy burger joi Explore
Seafood (13 places) When it comes to seafood in Reykjavik, you're in for a treat. From traditional Icelandic dishes like smoked salmon to innovative seafood fusion creations, the city has it all. Head to the Old Harbor a Explore
Fast Food (9 places) When visiting Reykjavik, sometimes you just need a quick and easy meal on the go. Luckily, Reykjavik offers a variety of fast food options to satisfy your cravings. From classic burgers and fries to i Explore
Asian (8 places) When it comes to Asian cuisine in Reykjavik, you'll find a variety of options to satisfy your cravings. From traditional Icelandic takes on sushi to authentic Vietnamese pho, the city offers a diverse Explore
Burgers (8 places) Explore
Thai (6 places) When it comes to Thai food in Reykjavik, you're in for a treat. From classic Pad Thai to spicy Tom Yum soup, you'll find a variety of dishes that will tantalize your taste buds. Head to the vibrant do Explore
Icelandic (5) • Pub (5) • Casual Dining (4) • Fine Dining (4) •

Explore More Restaurants Guides

Top 5 Restaurants in Reykjavik

Reykjavik, the capital of Iceland, is a food lover's paradise with a vibrant culinary scene offering a wide range of dining options. Here are the top 5 restaura

View guide →

Top Things To Do in Reykjavik

See All →

Top Things To Do in Reykjavik

Click to See All

We Are Part of the My Guide Network!

My Guide Reykjavik is part of the global My Guide Network of Online & Mobile travel guides. We are now in 180+ Destinations and Growing.

Nearby Destinations

My Guide Network Locations
Add to your trip
Day {[{day.day}]} {[{day.dateFormat}]}
{[{slotLabel(slot)}]}

Add your travel dates so we can place this on the right day, or save it for later.

Add to day {[{trip.popover.day}]}Add to trip Cancel